Is it possible that a continent brimming with cultural diversity, unexploited growth potential and incredible landscapes is inadvertently exporting its most precious resource — its people's health? The answer lies in the growing phenomenon of healthcare tourism. In Asia, many opt for domestic medical care, while over 650,000 Africans, including approximately 320,000 from the USA, seek medical treatment abroad annually. What compels these individuals to look elsewhere for healthcare services and how can this be reversed?
Healthcare tourism is not a new concept. Due to the value people attach to their health and well-being, getting quality medical attention is usually a priority. People travel around the world to seek healthcare in countries and facilities where they feel safe. Medical tourism is not only applicable to Africa. A report by the Centre for Disease Control and Prevention suggests that millions of US residents travel to another country each year for medical care. This is despite being ranked among the top 25 countries with the best public health system.
Healthcare tourism in Africa not only has extensive economic and developmental implications but it also affects the health and well-being of its citizens and thus addressing it is imperative. This article aims to unravel the causes, consequences, and above all, the strategies for reversing the tide of healthcare tourism in Africa. Before we dive deeper into the conversation, let’s explain healthcare tourism and what fuels it.
Healthcare tourism, also known as medical tourism, refers to the practice of people looking for healthcare services or medical treatment in foreign countries. This is often because of perceived inadequacies in the healthcare system of their country. Healthcare tourism involves various medical procedures, including specialized treatment, dental work, surgeries and wellness treatments. One of the major destinations for healthcare tourism is India, where each year thousands of African patients travel there seeking medical treatment.
The scope and scale of medical tourism in Africa have been the main subjects of various studies. According to reports by WHO, Africa bears 24% of the global disease burden but only houses 2% of the total number of doctors in the world and less than 1% of global health spending.
Why India?
In 2019, India had 595,000 healthcare tourists, a 22.3% increase from 2018. India’s popularity as a healthcare destination can be credited to its highly skilled professionals, advanced medical facilities, reduced waiting times, and cost-effectiveness for medical treatment. Although Canada, Japan, Singapore and the UK rank among the top countries with well-developed healthcare systems and have been considered options for various Africans, they have costly healthcare and challenging visa processes, unlike India, where visas are issued quickly, and treatment is more affordable.
The combination of affordability and high-quality medical care thus makes India a popular choice for Africans in search of medical treatment abroad. This underscores the urgent need for African countries to improve their healthcare services and infrastructure to lower the reliance on foreign healthcare services and thus preserve healthcare investments within the continent. Before we dive into the consequences of medical tourism in Africa, let’s look deeper into why Africans prefer offshore health treatment.
Causes of Healthcare Tourism in Africa
Various interrelated factors drive people to seek healthcare services abroad and thus the surge of healthcare tourism in Africa. The nexus of the majority of the issues arises from the insufficiencies within the local healthcare systems.
Healthcare systems in Africa are not delivering to expectations
The core driver of healthcare tourism in Africa is the inability of local healthcare systems to provide quality care. According to the National Institute of Health, only 52% of Africans have access to necessary healthcare services, impacting the continent's healthcare quality. Various countries in Africa grapple with the lack of funding in healthcare systems, resulting in prolonged waiting times, advanced medical treatment sparseness, and modern medical equipment scarcity for essential procedures. Patients thus opt to travel abroad, where they can access experienced specialists swiftly and conventional treatments.
Insufficient Healthcare Infrastructure and Facilities
Many nations in Africa struggle to enhance and maintain healthcare infrastructure, leading to ill-equipped and overcrowded hospitals. The lack of facilities including state-of-the-art surgery rooms, advanced diagnostic equipment and specialized care centres impels patients to look for treatment in countries that are more developed where these facilities are easily accessible.
Shortage of Skilled Medical Professionals
Among the major factors that play a significant role in healthcare tourism is the lack of skilled healthcare professionals from surgeons to doctors to specialized medical practitioners. Africa faces the most critical healthcare workforce shortage and by 2030, it is estimated to rise to 6.1 million. Most of the countries in Africa suffer from a brain drain as qualified medical professionals leave behind gaps in the local workforce driving patients seeking expertise to opt for countries with experienced and well-trained medical personnel increasing the healthcare tourism demand.
Perceived Lack of Trust in the Local Healthcare System
The perceptions of inadequate quality, corruption and inefficiency in healthcare abrade trust in the local healthcare amenities. On most occasions, the mistrust and negative experiences with local healthcare providers push individuals to look for care elsewhere. Although these perceptions do not always reflect the reality of the quality of healthcare services, they are controlling factors that support healthcare tourism.
Economic and Cultural Factors
Various economic and cultural factors such as the desire for privacy and affordability also remarkably contribute to medical tourism. Since medical treatment in some countries like India seems to be more cost-effective, this tends to encourage patients to travel abroad to seek the services. For instance, a kidney transplant in the US can cost up to $300,000 as compared to India where it costs around $13,000. In addition, cultural preferences and the desire for privacy drive patients to seek care in countries where they can communicate effectively and feel more comfortable with healthcare providers.
Consequences of Healthcare Tourism
Although healthcare tourism offers great benefits to individuals seeking various medical treatments, it also comes with a significant set of consequences for both patients and countries in Africa. The impacts have intense implications and are multifaceted and this emphasises the urgency of addressing this phenomenon.
Economic Impact on African Countries
When patients opt for international medical care, a significant amount of money flows into the various destination country’s economies, leaving the continent. Each year, Africa loses more than $1bilion to healthcare tourism, a figure notably lower than the annual expenditure of the United States at $2.3 billion. This outflow of capital tends to weaken the African health sector development. This hinders economic and healthcare infrastructure progression and deprives them of the resources that are required to enhance healthcare systems.
The Burden on Patients and Their Families
Medical tourism brings about an emotional and significant financial burden on the family and the patient. Seeking medical treatment abroad often involves high costs and this includes expenses for travel, accommodation, treatment, and follow-up care. Patients may experience anxiety and stress as they navigate through a healthcare system that is unfamiliar and the families have no other option but to bear the brunt of these financial burdens in a foreign country.
Loss of Talent and Medical Expertise
WHO 2018 report states that ‘’the African Region had 1.30 health workers per 1000 population, falling significantly short of the 4.5 per 1000 goal in the Sustainable Development Goals’’. As a consequence of healthcare tourism, the brain drain phenomenon leads to the migration of skilled medical professionals from countries in Africa to countries that are more economically developed such as the USA, UK and Canada. This results in a shortage of healthcare professionals in the home countries of patients. The loss of medical expertise and talent not only weakens the ability to train and retain local medical professionals but also impacts healthcare quality in Africa thus preventing the development of indigenous medical competence.
Reduced Investment in Local Healthcare Infrastructure
In 2016, Africans used more than $6 billion in outbound medical treatment. As a result of healthcare tourism, resources are diverted away from investment in local medical facilities. Countries in Africa struggling to retain patients' resources and skilled healthcare professionals find it challenging to allocate funds for upgrading and developing healthcare infrastructure as well as acquiring advanced medical equipment, ultimately impacting the overall quality of healthcare services.
Strategies for Reversing Healthcare Tourism
When it comes to medical tourism reversal in Africa, it needs a multi-dimensional approach. Various strategies can be used to motivate patients to choose local healthcare services over foreign alternatives, thus enhancing the African healthcare systems.
Improving Healthcare Infrastructure and Facilities
A rudimentary step in reversing healthcare tourism is improving local healthcare facilities and infrastructure. Countries in Africa should invest in diagnostic centres, specialized clinics, and cutting-edge hospitals. Reindustrializing facilities, supplying them with advanced medical technology such as MRIs, CT and PET scanners thus extending the accessibility of specialized services will greatly enhance the allurement of local healthcare systems.
Rebuilding Trust and Confidence in Local Healthcare Systems
When it comes to healthcare decision-making, trust is the cornerstone. African countries ought to work earnestly to build and maintain trust in their healthcare systems to reverse healthcare tourism. Open communication, accountability, and transparency with patients successfully restore patients’ confidence. Moreover, offering clear information about various treatment options and actively engaging patients and their families in care decisions significantly fosters trust in local healthcare services.
Promoting Medical Research and Innovation
To improve the range and quality of healthcare services available locally, it is important to invest in medical research and innovation. Revitalizing local research and development can lead to breakthroughs in medical technology and treatments, making it more likely that patients will find advanced care within their countries.
Investing in Medical Education and Training
African countries can retain their talent and increase their pool of skilled professionals by investing in medical training and education programs and enhanced compensation structures. For any healthcare system, there is nothing better than a well-trained and robust medical workforce. The brain drain effect can be reversed by offering incentives for medical professionals to work and stay in their countries.
Strengthening Healthcare Regulation and Standards
Enforcing and adopting rigorous healthcare standards and regulations is essential. This can be done by making certain that healthcare facilities adhere to quality standards, safety measures, and international best practices. African countries can thus assure patients that local healthcare facilities are as good as international healthcare systems.
One major factor that has greatly contributed to healthcare tourism is the concerns about medical negligence in Africa. If left unaddressed, cases of medical negligence significantly compromise patient safety. Lack of rigid regulations and standards creates an environment where accountability may be insufficient or unclear. Enforcing stringent standards and regulations and establishing clear consequences for medical negligence within the healthcare sector is essential in fostering confidence and enhancing the overall quality of healthcare systems.
Public-Private Partnerships to Enhance Healthcare Delivery
To bolster healthcare delivery in Africa, the public and private sectors need to collaborate. Involving the private sector in healthcare services can enhance efficiency, innovation and accessibility while lowering the burden on public healthcare systems.
Public Awareness and Advocacy
Public awareness and advocacy play a pivotal role in addressing healthcare tourism in Africa. Firstly, educating the public about the benefits and risks of healthcare tourism is crucial to enable informed decisions. Patients should be encouraged to explore domestic healthcare options thus strengthening local healthcare systems. Moreover, advocacy for healthcare reform and policy changes is fundamental in building an environment that promotes affordability, quality and trust within the local healthcare sector.
A call to action
Boasting nearly 15% of the global population, Africa holds immense untapped potential, surpassing the current market size by over tenfold. This demographic abundance not only presents an opportunity to prevent medical tourism but also acts as a catalyst for economic improvement across the continent. By harnessing this vast unexplored market, Africa can improve local healthcare infrastructure, redirect healthcare resources strategically and reinforce its economy while reducing expenditures for healthcare tourism.
The tenacity of reversing healthcare tourism in Africa cannot be overstated. Strengthening local healthcare systems is essential in mitigating the medical and economic burdens linked to healthcare tourism. To bring about positive change, collective efforts from healthcare professionals, governments, and the public are required. However, the responsibility for making necessary changes primarily rests on governments. We call upon governments to recognize the urgency of this issue and take proactive measures to transform the healthcare sector, providing world-class, accessible and reliable care for their citizens.
We're eager to hear your thoughts on our article about reversing healthcare tourism in Africa. Did it address your questions or concerns? Send us an email at team@fortrenandcompany.com. Your feedback is invaluable in shaping our content to better meet your needs.
If you have specific inquiries or need tailored information, reach out to our team at team@fortrenandcompany.com or +234 70 4934 2905.
